About Us

Why May Insurance Services?

May Insurance Services, Inc. is a full service brokerage agency. Established in 1990, we serve agents throughout Ohio.

May Insurance Services, Inc. specializes in medical, dental, disability and other ancillary insurance for individuals, businesses and seniors. We have a large product portfolio with multiple carriers.

May Insurance Services, Inc. is here to help you build your business. Our experienced staff will assist you with every aspect of sales and service.

May Insurance Services, Inc. is one of seven general agencies that constitute BrokerNet, Inc. This relationship gives us “Strength in Numbers” and leverage with carriers thereby allowing us to provide benefits that other smaller agencies can not. In particular, this allows us to develop enhanced relationships with carriers that benefit you and your clients.

Our Mission

  • Provide brokers with the best sales support available.
  • Provide brokers with all the necessary tools to provide the best possible service to their clients.

Our Promise

  • We are constantly searching for new and improved products and services to enhance our portfolio and are committed to serving you with honesty and integrity.

Meet The Team

The following is a brief description of your MIS team and each member's responsibilities.You will see that they provide years of experience and a willingness to assist you in any way they can. Please use this as a guide for any of your service-related issues.
John May
John began his career in the insurance business as a personal producer many years ago. He quickly learned that providing a superior level of expertise and service to his clients lead to more opportunities. After establishing himself as an Employee Benefits Expert, he founded May Insurance Services over 25 years ago as a way to share his knowledge and sales skills with other insurance brokers. Today, he focuses his talents on the strategic planning and further development of MIS through strong carrier, broker and employee relationships. Treating everyone with honesty, integrity and respect has proven to be a successful formula for John and the entire MIS team.


Scott Lewis
Scott LewisMarketing Director for Group Medical Productsslewis@mayinsurance.com - Ext 208
Scott’s tenured career in the health and life insurance business spans over three decades. His extensive background along with his NAHU self-funding advisor certification make him an invaluable resource to all. While focusing his efforts on the employer group market, he is able to help brokers traverse this complex marketplace with creative solutions for all group sizes. Scott’s top priority is supporting brokers by providing the best solutions along with outstanding and reliable service.
Jackie Turner
Jackie TurnerMarketing Director for Group Ancillary and Individual Productsjturner@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 216
With an extensive background in broker support, Jackie knows what it takes to get the job done. Her product knowledge and world class sales support in the health insurance brokerage community is unparalleled. She champions MIS group ancillary sales, as well as promotes all individual medical & ancillary product sales. Jackie is a wealth of knowledge and stands ready to help.
Russ Simonsen
Russ SimonsenMarketing Director for Senior Productsrsimonsen@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 212
Innovative solutions, top-notch customer service and loyal relationships are what make Russ the perfect resource for brokers and clients alike in the senior marketplace. As MIS’ Medicare Mentor, he can help navigate through various product options to find a solution that works best to fit your specific needs. His longevity and expertise in the health insurance business and with MIS, make him an industry leader and someone that everyone wants to work with.
Mindy Van Order
Mindy Van OrderMarketing Manager/Group Renewal Specialistmvanorder@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 218
The backbone of the MIS Marketing Team, Mindy utilizes her vast experience in the insurance field to support all lines of coverage at MIS. In addition to coordinating broker meetings, webinars & communications, she also spearheads group renewal activity – negotiating with the carriers on behalf of our brokers to minimize rate increases and manage benefit plan changes. Everyone who works with Mindy raves about her follow through and incredible broker support.


Karla Bennett
Karla BennettQuoting Specialist & Agent Licensing (Group)kbennett@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 211
Another MIS team member with multiple decades of health insurance experience, Karla leads our group medical and ancillary quoting division, as well as handling group carrier appointments & licensing. Even though she juggles multiple responsibilities, Karla thrives on providing quick & accurate turn-around in everything she does.
Julie Leppert
Julie LeppertIndividual & Senior New Business Coordinatorjleppert@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 201
Tackling the responsibility of all individual and senior new business administration and service is no small task – but Julie Leppert’s background in benefits administration has equipped her to manage and thrive in this key role. Her problem solving skill set and conscientious attention to detail make her a wonderful resource to everyone working with her. Need help with individual medical, senior or ancillary administration – reach out to Julie today!
David Linn
David LinnChief Financial Officer, Operations & HRdlinn@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 210
In addition to supervising all Human Resource activity at MIS, Dave is responsible for overseeing the daily operations of our fast-paced office. His vast management experience combined with a straight-forward and caring approach to a job well-done are clear in everything he gets involved in. And, did you know he is a Wrap Doc expert? What is a Wrap Doc? You can’t afford to miss out on this opportunity - ask Dave today!
Rhonda Murray
Rhonda MurrayAccount Managerrmurray@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 209
Rhonda’s extensive background in benefits administration make her the perfect resource to handle all specialized account management needs. Her “can-do” problem solving attitude and prioritized focus on providing world class customer service are evident in everything she does and the results she obtains.
Lynette Jones
Lynette JonesBusiness Analystljones@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 213
With her extensive background in business analytics and accounting, Lynette is more than up to the challenge of handling broker commissions, production and financial reporting as well as data analysis in our ever-evolving business.
Jodi Lewis
Jodi LewisGroup New Business Coordinatorjlewis@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 205
Managing all group new business and service is no easy task – which is why we have our own “Super-Woman” – Jodi - tackling the job. She works with brokers to ensure a seamless and efficient new sales submission process. And, once the group is in place, she safeguards that group by assisting brokers with any and all service-related items post issue. No matter how busy she gets, Jodi finds a way to give personalized attention to each broker and their specific needs.
Susan May
Susan MayBrokerNet Administration/Special Projectssmay@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 214
Our own “fountain of knowledge,” Susan utilizes her years of insurance carrier experience to support both MIS and BrokerNet in multiple agency aspects including, but not limited to: marketing ideas, sales support, incentives, communications, agent payroll and strategic planning.