About Us

Why May Insurance Services?

May Insurance Services, Inc. is a full service brokerage agency. Established in 1990, we serve agents throughout Ohio.

May Insurance Services, Inc. specializes in medical, dental, disability and other ancillary insurance for individuals, businesses and seniors. We have a large product portfolio with multiple carriers.

May Insurance Services, Inc. is here to help you build your business. Our experienced staff will assist you with every aspect of sales and service.

Our Mission

  • Provide brokers with the best sales support available.
  • Provide brokers with all the necessary tools to provide the best possible service to their clients.

Our Promise

  • We are constantly searching for new and improved products and services to enhance our portfolio and are committed to serving you with honesty and integrity.

May Insurance Services, Inc.
is your local BrokerNet, Inc. affiliate

BrokerNet, Inc. is Ohio agents' #1 source for health, life and ancillary insurance. With offices located across the state, BrokerNet, Inc. is dedicated to providing…
  • Superior products
  • Exceptional sales support & personalized service
  • Competitive compensation
  • Comprehensive market knowledge & industry experience
  • Exciting incentives & value-added agent benefits

BrokerNet, Inc. was founded in 1998 and consists of several Managing General Agencies strategically located across the state to give exceptional support and personalized, local service. Our commitment is to provide agents & their clients with tailored solutions that best meet their needs at the most affordable cost.  
BrokerNet, Inc. has multiple insurance carrier relationships that allow us to find the best fit for our agents & their clients.

BrokerNet, Inc. collectively represents over 200 years of insurance industry experience. Our vast market & product knowledge along with quality training and effective communications keeps agents up-to-date with the ever-changing marketplace.

BrokerNet, Inc. offers many benefits & incentives that smaller agencies cannot, while preserving & promoting a personalized relationship that is often lost in large, multi-state agencies.

BrokerNet, Inc. provides the back office sales support agents can rely on so they can focus on what they do best.  We are here to help you grow your business.

BrokerNet's Pledge
To provide exceptional support & personalized service to our agents and their clients with the utmost honesty & highest level of integrity.

May Insurance Services, Inc.
is your local BrokerNet, Inc. affiliate.

Visit BrokerNet, Inc. online at www.brokernetinc.com.

Meet The Team

The following is a brief description of your MIS team and each member's responsibilities.You will see that they provide years of experience and a willingness to assist you in any way they can. Please use this as a guide for any of your service-related issues.
John May
John MayPresidentjmay@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 202
John began his insurance career in 1976 as an agent and has specialized in the employee benefit area since 1980. In October 1990, John founded May Insurance Services, Inc. He concentrates his efforts on agency development.


Scott Lewis
Scott LewisMarketing Director for Group Medical Productsslewis@mayinsurance.com - Ext 208
Scott has been involved in the insurance business for over 30 years. His primary focus is promoting group products to current and prospective brokers. He understands the complexity of today’s marketplace and uses his tremendous experience and knowledge to find creative solutions with the right product and price. He is also a NAHU self-funding certified advisor.
Jackie Turner
Jackie TurnerMarketing Director for Group Ancillary and Individual Productsjturner@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 216
Jackie is a veteran of the health insurance business. She comes with an extensive background in the Group, Ancillary, Individual and Senior markets and is here to assist you with all such related needs. She spent the last 14 years working in a large agency supporting brokers just like you.
Russ Simonsen
Russ SimonsenMarketing Director for Senior Productsrsimonsen@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 212
Russ has been in the health insurance business his entire career, spanning more than 40 years. His primary focus is helping agents navigate the complex world of senior sales. His vast product knowledge makes him a great broker resource.
Mindy Van Order
Mindy Van OrderMarketing Coordinator/Group Renewal Specialistmvanorder@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 218
Mindy has over 20 years experience in the insurance field. Her responsibilities range from group health and ancillary renewals to broker education and training. She also provides group ancillary sales support and coordinates MIS' marketing efforts.


Karla Bennett
Karla BennettQuoting Specialist & Agent Licensing (Group)kbennett@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 211
Karla has over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry. Her responsibilites include quoting for group medical and ancillary. She also is the go-to person on group carrier appointments and licensing.
David Linn
David LinnChief Financial Officer, Operations & HRjturner@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 216
Dave has over 33 years of experience in financial and operational management with businesses of all shapes and sizes. His understanding of business practices and common sense make him an asset to the agency.
Lyn Seiple
Lyn SeipleService & Communicationslseiple@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 209
Lyn has 15 years in the insurance field. Her attention to detail is critical as she services and manages John's individual, senior, and group business. She also creates publications/broadcasts and assists Scott with administrative duties.
Jodi Lewis
Jodi LewisGroup New Business Coordinatorjlewis@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 205
Jodi has more than 28 years of experience in the medical and life insurance fields. Her extensive knowledge of carriers and processes allow her to accurately submit, service and manage group business.
Susan May
Susan MayBrokerNet Administration/Special Projectssmay@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 214
A "fountain of knowledge," Susan acts as a consultant to BrokerNet and MIS. She is transitioning MIS to paperless record keeping and streamlining our client database, report generation and much more.
Brent Wells
Brent WellsBusiness Analyst and Commissionsbwells@mayinsurance.com - Ext. 213
Brent has 6 years of experience in the financial industry. His CPA skills are crucial for his primary responsibilities at MIS, which include broker commissions, reporting and analytics.